Assets or Commodities? Comparing Regulations of Placement and Protection of Migrant Workers in Indonesia and the Philippines

Dinita Setyawati


In labor-abundant countries, migrant workers are considered state assets and the government often calls them the ‘economic heroes’ of the nation. Yet by maximizing economic benefits, the protection of labor migrants is often neglected by both origin and host countries. The state’s assumed presence in protecting its nationals is tied to its capacity to ‘control’ migration flows and protect its nationals abroad. Within this framework, the regulations concerning migrant workers’ protection in Indonesia and the Philippines, which comprise the two largest exporters of migrant labor in South-East Asia, are assessed. This paper compares the two key laws in both countries: Indonesian Law No. 39/2004 and the Philippine Republic Act (RA) No. 10022. In this context, it also aims to answer the following question: Are Filipinos better protected than Indonesians? Looking specifically into the state and the economy, the history of workers’ protection, and key aspects of the law, this paper recognizes several weaknesses of the Indonesian government’s migrant workers protection scheme, especially in the aspects of educating workers and defining the responsibilities of government agencies. Thus, strong commitment from the government, along with close monitoring by civil society, is needed to ensure better protection for citizens.


Labor Law; Labor Migration; Migrant Workers; Philippines

Full Text:



Amnesty International. (2011). Indonesia: Parliament continues to fail domestic workers. Retrieved from

Antique, & Ahniar, N. F. (2010, September 23). Sumbangan TKI ke cadangan devisa naik tajam. Vivanews. Retrieved from

Aquino III, B. (2010, June 30). President Benigno “Noynoy” Aquino inaugural speech. Retrieved from

Benahi serius nasib 6 juta buruh migran. (2011, December 19). Kompas. Retrieved from

Bohning, W. R. (1988). The protection of migrant workers and international labor standards. International Migration, 26(2), 133-146.

Day, T. (2002). Fluid iron, state formation in Southeast Asia. Honolulu, HI: University of Hawai’i Press.

Ford, M., Lyons, L., & Van Schendel, W. (2012). Labour migration and human trafficking. In M. Ford, L. Lyons, & W. van Schendel (Eds.), Labour migration and human trafficking in Southeast Asia: Critical perspectives (pp. 1-19). London, UK: Routledge.

Gonzales, J. (1998). Philippine labor migration: Critical dimensions of public policy. Singapore: Institute of Southeast Asian Studies (ISEAS).

Guild, E., & Mantu, S. (2011). Introduction. In E. Guild & S. Mantu (Eds.), Constructing and imagining labor migration: Perspectives of control from five continents (pp. 1-11). Surrey, UK: Ashgate Publications Limited.

Garces-Mascarenas, B. (2011). Labor migration regulation in Malaysia. A policy of high numbers and low rights. In E. Guild & S. Mantu (Eds.), Constructing and imagining labor migration: Perspectives of control from five continents (pp. 65-86). Surrey, UK: Ashgate Publishing Limited.

Haryanto, A. (2011, December 21). Agen TKI ilegal di Condet Digerebek. detikNews. Retrieved from

House of Representatives (2012, April 12). DPR sahkan RUU perlindungan pekerja migran. Retrieved from

Indonesia to encourage ASEAN migrant worker protection. (2011, March 9). Hukum Online. Retrieved from

International Organization for Migration [IOM]. (2012). Labor migration from Indonesia. An overview of Indonesian migration to selected destinations in Asia and the Middle East. Jakarta, Indonesia: IOM.

International Labor Organization [ILO]. (2011, October 4). The long journey of justice for Indonesian migrant workers. Retrieved from

International Labor Organization [ILO]. (2009). Protecting the rights of migrant workers: A shared responsibility. Geneva, Italy: ILO.

Liu, H. (2012, February 29). Presiden perpanjang satgas TKI. Kompas. Retrieved from

Migrante International. (2012). Five cases of “Noynoying” on OFW issues. Retrieved from

Migrant workers in Saudi Arabia, beheading the golden goose. (2011, July 3). The Economist. Retrieved from

National Agency for the Placement and Protection of Indonesian Migrant Workers [BNP2TKI]. (2011). Sejarah penempatan TKI. Retrieved from

OFWs score Aquino failure to meet inauguration promise. (2012, February 16). Sunstar. Retrieved from

Prihadiyoko, I. (2012, December 1). BNP2TKI-IOM kerja sama pemberdayaan TKI korban trafficking. Kompas. Retrieved from

Ruhs, M., & Martin, P. (2010). Numbers versus rights in low-skilled labor immigration policy? A comment on Cummins and Rodríguez. Journal of Human Development and Capabilities, 11(2), 305-309.

Ruslan, H. (2012, June 23). Tiga TKI ditembak mati polisi Malaysia, LSM desak pemerintah mengusut. Republika Online. Retrieved from

Safitri, A. (2012, March 28). Kisah BMI Taiwan diperas di bandara Soekarno-Hatta. Retrieved from

Susilo, W. (2010, February 3). Agenda pembaharuan kebijakan perburuhan. Retrieved from

Syaiful, A. (2009, June 11). Nestapa buruh migran. Retrieved from

TKI Bermasalah di Malaysia 1.170 Kasus (2009). Antaranews. Retrieved from

Tyner, J. (2000). Migrant labor and the politics of scale. Gendering the Philippine state. Asia Pacific Viewpoint, 41(2), 131-154.

Wickramasekara, P. (2006, February 17). Labor migration in Asia, role of bilateral agreements and MOUs. ILO presentation at the JIPLT workshop on International Migration and Labor Market in Asia, Tokyo. Retrieved from

Workers send home $6 billion. (2012, January 2). The Jakarta Post. Retrieved from

World Bank. (2008). The Malaysia-Indonesia remittance corridor. Making formal transfers the best option for women and undocumented migrants. Retrieved from


World Bank. (2011). World Development Indicators (Edition: September 2011). ESDS International, University of Manchester. Retrieved from

Women’s Feature Services. (2010). Justice and healing for survivors of gender-based violence. Retrieved from

Women’s Feature Services. (2010). The impact of female migration on Filipino families and strengthening support systems in the community. Retrieved from

Yudhoyono, S. B. (2011). Statement by H. E. Dr Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono, President of the Republic of Indonesia, at the 100th International Labour Conference. Retrieved from:




  • There are currently no refbacks.

License URL:

This website is part of